At first, I wondered about the Jessica incident…I have been voting for her from the beginning, but slacked off the week she was in the bottom 3…felt confident that she was doing well.
In other words, the voting is fluent for the most part…rarely is it consistent as last year.. Every week is a new beginning. At this point, they are all good. Colton did have an off night. Doing something new should not be penalized, but if you do something new at this stage in the game it has to soar. I still voted and voted for Colton as I genuinely like him. This for me, has been the most boring season and I have watched since the very beginning.
Colton showed class at the end — total class. This kid will go far, and I for one will support him. Hollie has never recieved a standing ovation either althought she deserved one this week!!! I did not expect Colton to go home last night, and was convinced that it was going to be my favorite Hollie last night when Elise was sent to safety. I was not surprised that Hollie was in the bottom 3, but I thought she would have been the first one sent to safety.
All the Hollie fans out there…Keep Voting!!!!! She deserves to make it to the end. I think now that Colton has been eliminated PP is guaranteed to be in the final 2. I agree! Hollie was perfect.
I think every week the jugdes take it on her! She seems so scared! What about Jessica? No way! She has a good voice, but joshua is better, and Hollie has a stronger voice, just need to let go a little bit. Jessica looks like an 80 year-old frog each time she goes out, she overdoes and overdresses too! I vote for Phillip-Hollie-Joshua and somebody please make elise go home once and for all!
She can sing sometimes better than others but it is painful to watch her sing! Kris, i agree with u. Hollie should b in top 3 or 4.
If she is in top 2, i want her and Jessica. I think some people who are trying to analyze the voting demographics and reasons why people vote the way they do have forgotten to take into account the votes from those whose favorites have been eliminated. Why do you think that someone is good only if he gets standing ovation from J.
Jimmy definitely keeps it real. He is another Simon and I love it! That is why he is more and more visible. Did we see or hear him at all when Simon was still here? The producers only brought him out because the three supposed jugdes that they have are not worth a dime.
Just goes to show every performance has to be great at this point. All six left are good performers, each one has to have a great night to remain. This is what it is all about. I think at this point it will be whoever has a poor night on Wed will be eliminated on Thurs.
Colton was always consistent and stayed true to himself. As a whole, I think he deserved to be in the top 4 if based on what has he been doing in the competition.. I still love him. All the best for all the remaining contestants! I think the producers showed that clip of Colton being cocky to lower the impact of him being voted off the show.
They are all talented! Stop all the trash talk.. He has to go. How on earth Steven Tyler strings a sentence together let alone a critique is beyond me!
Jimmy is amazing and knows talent when he sees it and also knows how to talk constructively unlike the 2 male judges! Educate yourself please. The most insane act yet,I hope this young man makes it big,and thumbs his nose at the judges, Who I blame for this,had they not acted like Idiots about America sendin Sanchez home,A wonderful singer could have been saved. I am not sure of the honesty anymore of this program. We have decided to go with Voice and XFactor.
Idol needs three new Judges in order to stay alive another season. But did they decide or the fans? Please enlighten me. For me the two was a bad decissions, no only Colton…. I will not be watching the show anymore.
The Fix is in….. Me too! I will not be watching this show anymore… I think this season the judges were using the wrong save for the wrong people!!! You really think JLo has that much influence on the voters? And Colton deserved the critique on his second song. Jessica Sanchez,, Phillip Phillips,, Skylar Laine-6,, Joshua Ledet-2,, 5. Elise Testone-1,, 2. Hollie Cavanagh, 1. Colton Dixon, 0. If this voting trend continues, Skylar, Phillip and Jessica will be in the final 3, with Phillip and Jessica in the finale, with Jessica winning it all.
I think we are supposed to believe this is a legitimate leak but the more and more I think about it I think these numbers serve the same purpose as all of the other charades on the show this season. They are going to desperate measures to compete with other shows this year and this is part of it. If you look back over the numbers that were released over the past weeks it makes absolutely no sense. I think pcosmachine multiplied the percentages by 53 million to come up with those numbers ending in double zeros.
I agree, you have to take these figures with a grain of salt not knowing where it came from. Rounding to the nearest hundreds by the way is not an uncommon practice. I was very sad to see Colton go, but I am afraid it is down to the wire, and every song has to be great.. He is a wonderful person and will go far with or without American Idol. I still think that Jessica should have gone…but she is also good, just boring to me.
Phillip, Skylar for the win. This is very hard to tell.. Jessica and Joshua are the only real singer on the show and they are one to beat. The rest is meh!! Lo have set next to me and I should be forced to listen to her squeaking voice I should be drifting away too!
America got it right. Colton is talented but out of that group he was one of the most inconsistent competitors. He had two horrible performances the other night and had a really bad performance two to three weeks ago that was by far the worst out of all of the competitors at the time.
Out of the 7 that were left he was the least talented vocally he deserved to be eliminated. Looking forward to seeing you in concert, my best wishes and Prayers are with you Colton Dixon! Skylar is still my favorite idol, just enjoy all her stage performances. I am tired of the judges belittling her performances. Industry has many good singers and Adele is a proof. Jessica is good, but there are a lot of black american girls that sings like or better than her.
In the AI auditions this year there were two girls very talented and carismatic: Gabi Carruba and Ashley Robles, remember? Love, love , love Phillip!!!! Colton was the most talented one on the show. His performances were always different each week. Elise as well. Hollie has a great voice but no performance skills.
Jessica has the best voice but Colton was a true artist, musician and songwriter. He is the only one that I could see in concert or listen to his whole cd without wanting to kill myself. I loved Phillip but all of his performances are the same. I did like the Usher song until the end. The point being that I vote for who I think would put out a great cd and put on an awesome concert.
No one wants to go to a concert or buy cd and every song is the same!! Jessica is boring, wonderful voice but Jimmy was right…wrong songs, Elise sang Zepplin-Whole lot of Love, fantastic but the other songs she picks are wrong , maybe some Joplin or Etta James or Josh Stone….
Have you noticed Phillip and Elise seem to be getting close? And Phillip seems to be a nice guy after all. He cares for Jessica too.
So there you got dude. Not being harsh, just practical. Lee DeWyze won and went nowhere. Ruben won and went nowhere. Taylor won and went nowhere. Sure you can vote your fingers off, but how cruel is it to win and then watch it all disappear?
Lee, Ruben and Taylor were all grown adults when they won and then lost. But at 16 and having a super ambitious stage mother, how hard is that going to be on Jessica? Jessica is different from Lee, Ruben and Taylor.
Jessica is more talented than them i think. Did she take herself to try out for AGT when she was 10 or 11 years old? Her dad was gone in the army. Who do you think has pushed her since childhood? Do the math. I have not liked Colton from day one! He is boring, boring, boring. The music was too loud and over powered Colton this week. The season started out with that problem but I thought they fixed it.
Colon was always amazing should not have went home. I have heard many ppl complain that when they went to vote for Colton a message said it was not a working number. Makes me wonder if it is rigged….. And this week when Colton was booted off, everyone else was crying or shocked, but not Skylar. She had that smug air about her of good, now I have a better chance.
Did anyone else see that? I agree. Colton was so nice with Hollie and Elise. I hope she goes home next week.
Okay, honestly…stop. Maybe she was shocked. But, of course, beneath all that…every single one of them is happy. It means they are that much closer to the title. Never liked Skylar, her countenance nor her voice nor her fashion sense. But she has good stage presence which means nothing to me. She tries her best to be likable but failed with me up to now.
I was even surprised she got into the Top The 3 judges are useless. Yes, they are stooges. Why do they have to give standing in unison?
Saw Randy nudging JLo to stand for Josua. And I thought it was much worse when Ryan informed Elise that she would have to watch one of her friends go home, she started laughing and smiling. He is awesome and I believe he will put out some great music.
Sharon from Murfreesboro, TN. Somebody forgot the all caps rule again. Hollie and Elise are 2 damn lucky girls……they should have even been gone before Deandre……. Yep thats why Elise was 5 times in the bottom of 3 and was the first girl who was eliminated and Hollie ….. But, at this point, they are all good and one slip up can cost you.
One thing I notice is how polarizing Jessica is. Either you love her or hate her with a passion and the comments point that out. Controversy, whether bad or good, ends up being good in the long run. One thing I do know is that it translates to money. Really liked Colton but after last 2 weeks not surprised he out, should have stayed true to his own style, too much influence by idol. Colton will have no problem getting a record deal!!! Good luck Colton, you will become famous some day!!! But that is just my opinion, to each his own.
Seems like many of them took the night off from voting thinking, like myself, Colton was safe. Then ur Asian Vegas lounge singer.. Phil is the best thing on the show now.
Dear Kariboceks, This is Simion Cowel, producer of the show. Sorry to hear you will stop watching now that Colton is yesturdays news. Goodbye, we will miss you. So many people try to sing Adele songs and they always sound bad but Hollie did a great job. Judges gave her praise but not enough imo. Hollie is a good singer but has to learn a lot. Less pitch problems. I actually like cd, but his creativity was too mich for the people. Great musician but his vocal quality is the least among the 7.
My vote goes to jessica. Hope she gets her gears back. I have to agree, Amrican Idol lost a lot of it intagrity when Simon left the show. And with the lower than expected rating for X-factor this season, it might happen.
We can only hope. Did anyone notice how freaking disrespectful Colton was when the judges for the first time criticized his performance. Maybe that is why people voted him off? Can you imagine what the Bible belt Biddies would say if Elise answered that same question in the exact same way. Are you proud of what you did?
Voting for two hrs for one contestant is why a deserving idol gets eliminated. He did not do anything wrong here. It is within the legal venues of voting system. You should do the same for your favorite. Hollie has a freaking amazing voice for such a small girl. Her first song the performed this week was as good or better than anything Jessica did this season.
If she keeps it up, she could be the darkhorse contender that Haley Rhiehart became last season. Hollie DID have a great performance last Wednesday.
So not consistent. American idol wil never be what it used to be in my opinion david archuleta was the best season even the new stage they have is way too much theyr tryna compete with The Voice and Xfactor they just need to keep doin what they were doing American idol adverages 19 million viewers during the week The Voice adverages 13 million viewers every week and suprisingly XFACTOR USA get about 12 million when it on air american idol needs to get their act together before simon cowell gain the thrown back.
Please check your spelling, grammar and most of all syntax. You vote for who you think is the best and appeals to you. Whoever gets the least number of votes that night is voted off. I sometimes wonder if people can hear. Sure the rest of the crew here are great singers , but, are we tired of hearing the same thing yet?
When you have someone like COLTON that can sing anything, perform and write songs you should never let them go they are a mark of a true artist. Just my thought. Trying to sing a fun, lively song in a dramatic, emotional style fell flat. Judges need to stop over praising their favorites and add some constructive criticism or caution to help prevent wrong song choices. I think Jessica was worthy of the save.
Colton seemed so fake to me. Like a hypocrite standing on the street corner saying his prayers so everyone would hear Matt. It made me sick. If you ever check out his twitter of FB he was always posting something about scriptures and Jesus.
The producers told him to stop doing it b. Also, he switched the lyrics last night to including God and to say He is all i need…. This was at a point when votes and what the producers thought didnt matter. Just give them the benefit of the doubt. PP, Josh are great but in different genres! The girls are a force too but these two boys are on another level. And I will not be disappointed whoever wins.
I think Jimmy spoke the truth, Only some of these kids are going to make it in the real world, because there is so much more to it than just being a great singer. Still I like the show. I am already in but next year I will try not to get into the show unless they make some big changes. Getting rid of two judges would be ideal. With Colton, who can guess? He had two subpar performances Wednesday night, but he's been less than stellar in the past, with little consequence.
Perhaps we've finally gotten to the point in the season where one minor slip up can cost you the season, no matter who you are and how great your hair looks. Seriously, first DeAndre's hair, now Colton's. What's left? This is troubling.
Either way, one couldn't help but feel like justice had been served when Colton's name was announced, following a comment he made after his performance the previous night that had not been aired until then. He apologized later, saying that he wasn't himself, but of course, the damage had already been done. Joining Colton in the bottom three were two singers you'd pretty much expect to be there: Hollie Cavanagh and Elise Testone.
More surprising was that, of the three, it was Elise who was given good news first. I for one am glad, because perhaps she can take the advice Jimmy gave her more rock 'n' roll!
In Hollie's case Along the way, we were visited by two "Idol" alums, both of whom won their respective seasons and then vanished from the face of the earth. Taylor Hicks , who was given a prime seat about halfway into the audience, announced that he'll be playing in Las Vegas this summer.
Then he sang us out with a wonderful vocal true to his faith. Phillip Phillips looked darn near incolsolable. The other emotion? Two weeks in a row, he was forced to sing country duets with Skylar Laine. This is a guy who wants to sing Christian rock, American Idol.
Not country. Even Colton admitted he was a little frustrated when he found out about the second country duet. Then came this week and the Now and Then theme. Namely Skylar and Colton. Colton Dixon results show Top 7. Related Posts. Colton Dixon tops Christian albums chart for 3rd time. New single out, new album coming from Colton Dixon. Pimp spot? Jessica and Skylar?
0コメント